Tipping Out Your Staff
The rise of digital payments has revolutionized the way we conduct transactions, making it faster, more convenient, and increasingly cashless. However, this shift has created a dilemma for fast-casual employees who have long relied on cash tips to supplement their income.
As patrons increasingly opt for credit cards, Apple Pay, and other digital payment methods, the traditional practice of management tipping out employees at the end of each shift has become a logistical nightmare. In this article, we'll explore the various methods employers can use to adapt to this new reality, each with its own set of benefits and drawbacks.
Method 1: Taking Cash from the Drawer
One approach is to continue taking cash from the drawer to tip out employees at the end of each shift. This method requires the owner or manager to set aside a portion of the daily cash intake specifically for tipping purposes. While this approach maintains the traditional practice of daily tipping, it creates a set of problems. For instance, daily trips to the bank to replenish cash funds can be time-consuming and inconvenient. Moreover, having large amounts of cash on hand can be a security risk and make it difficult to track and manage.
Method 2: Creating a Petty Cash Fund
Another option is to create a dedicated petty cash fund specifically for tipping out employees. This approach requires setting aside a fixed amount of cash each week or month, which can be used to tip out employees at the end of each shift. While this method provides a more organized approach to tipping, it still requires semi-regular trips to the bank to replenish funds and can still be quite difficult to track and manage.
Method 3: Digital Tipping via Venmo or Cash App
A more modern approach is to use digital payment platforms like Venmo or Cash App to tip out employees nightly. This method allows owners or managers to send tips directly to employees' digital wallets, eliminating the need for cash altogether. While this approach is convenient and easy to track, it may require employees to have a Venmo or Cash App account, which can be a barrier for some. It also creates a separate issue for the owners or management as they most probably will need a separate bank account specifically for this service and the necessary reserves linked to that app.
Method 4: Adding Tips to Paychecks
Perhaps the most straightforward approach is to add tips to employees' weekly or bi-weekly paychecks. This method eliminates the need for daily cash handling and provides a more streamlined approach to tipping. However, this approach can be met with resistance from employees who are accustomed to receiving daily tips. Many employees rely on daily tips to supplement their income and may feel that adding tips to paychecks is a significant change to their compensation structure.
Method 5: Adapting to the New Reality
The final approach is to simply tell employees that they must adapt to the new reality of digital payments. This approach requires employees to adjust their expectations and find alternative ways to supplement their income. While this approach may be the most cost-effective and efficient, it can be met with resistance from employees who feel that their livelihoods are being disrupted.
The Benefits and Drawbacks of Each Approach
Each of the above approaches has its own set of benefits and drawbacks. Here's a summary:
| Method | Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|---|
| Taking Cash from the Drawer | Maintains traditional practice of daily tipping | Requires daily trips to the bank, creates security risks, and is difficult to track |
| Creating a Petty Cash Fund | Provides a more organized approach to tipping | Requires regular trips to the bank, can be difficult to track and manage |
| Digital Tipping via Venmo or Cash App | Convenient, easy to track, and eliminates cash handling | Requires employees to have a Venmo or Cash App account |
| Adding Tips to Paychecks | Streamlines tipping process, eliminates cash handling | Can be met with resistance from employees, changes compensation structure |
| Adapting to the New Reality | Cost-effective, efficient | Can be met with resistance from employees, disrupts traditional tipping practices |
Conclusion
The shift towards digital payments has created a tipping dilemma for fast-casual employees. While there is no one-size-fits-all solution, employers can choose from a range of approaches to adapt to this new reality. Whether it's taking cash from the drawer, creating a petty cash fund, using digital payment platforms, adding tips to paychecks, or simply telling employees to adapt, each approach has its own set of benefits and drawbacks. Ultimately, the key to success lies in finding a solution that balances the needs of both employers and employees, while also embracing the changing landscape of digital payments.
Are your employees upset about the new tipping model? We can help!
If you are interested in private consulting, do not hesitate to hit the button below!