New Year's Resolutions #1: Pull the Plug

There is a magic hour in a restaurant that feels ceremonial, almost sacred. The lights dim just a touch. Glasses clink. The room hums with the low percussion of conversation, forks brushing plates, a server calling “behind” as if it were a prayer. This is the sound of commerce doing what it has done for centuries—feeding people, lubricating connection, making a little money while doing something honest.

Then someone plugs in an amplifier.

I’ve seen it happen more times than I care to count. The owner’s heart is in the right place. Live music feels romantic, generous, human. It recalls some half-remembered night in New Orleans or Barcelona or a smoky bar where the guitar was out of tune and everything tasted better because of it. Music, we tell ourselves, creates vibe. Vibe creates loyalty. Loyalty creates sales.

And yet, as soon as the first chord rings out, food revenue tanks.

Not metaphorically. Not eventually. Immediately.

Tickets slow. The kitchen, which had been dancing a respectable waltz, suddenly limps. Tables linger. Menus close and stay closed. People stop ordering that second round, that dessert, that extra side they didn’t need but wanted. The music has become the main course, and the food—your food—has been demoted to garnish.

Operators know this feeling in their bones. You can see it in the way managers start hovering near the POS, staring at numbers like gamblers willing the dice to turn. You can hear it in the forced optimism: “Once the crowd settles, they’ll order.” They won’t. They came for the show, not the short rib.

Then come the cover charges.

Few things curdle goodwill faster than an unexpected cover charge in a restaurant. A bar, maybe. A club, certainly. But a restaurant? Did the customers sign up for this? Did they agree that their Tuesday night pasta would now come with an admission fee? Watch their faces when the host explains it—polite confusion sliding into quiet resentment. They didn’t budget for this. They didn’t ask for it. And now, whether they stay or go, the mood has shifted.

Servers feel it next. They always do. Good servers are intuitive creatures. They read rooms the way sailors read weather. When live music starts, their instincts short-circuit. Do I approach the table now or wait until the song ends? Am I blocking someone’s view? Am I interrupting a moment? The result is hesitation, and hesitation is death in hospitality.

Service slows not because the staff is lazy or disengaged, but because they are suddenly unsure of their role. Are they caretakers of a dining experience or ushers in a concert hall? The choreography they’ve mastered no longer fits the music. Tips suffer. Confidence erodes. The room feels… off.

And let’s talk about volume, the eternal enemy.

Live music, unless exquisitely managed, has a way of creeping. It starts reasonable. Then the drummer can’t hear himself. Then the guitarist wants a little more in the monitor. Suddenly guests are leaning across tables, shouting questions they don’t care about just to justify the effort. Conversation—the lifeblood of dining—is strangled. The room becomes something else entirely.

Cut the music.

It is a restaurant, not a club.

This distinction matters more than most operators want to admit. Restaurants are built for flow: of people, of plates, of conversation, of money. Clubs are built for spectacle. They ask guests to surrender to the moment, to stay put, to watch. These are opposing goals. When you blur them, one will always suffer. And it is almost never the band.

For every venue that truly benefits from live music—where it is baked into the brand, the architecture, the expectation—ten places suffer quietly, night after night, convinced that the problem must be something else. The menu. The staff. The neighborhood. Anything but the obvious.

There are exceptions, of course. There always are. The Sunday jazz brunch that hums softly in the background, never demanding attention. The acoustic duo in the corner who understand they are there to support, not star. The late-night set after the kitchen has closed, when food sales are no longer the metric that matters. These work because they respect the hierarchy of needs. Food first. Music second.

Nostalgia is a powerful drug. Many of us fell in love with restaurants because of places where music and food blurred beautifully. But memory edits ruthlessly. It removes the empty tables, the stressed servers, the owner in the office staring at a P&L that refuses to make sense. What remains is a feeling, and feelings are expensive to chase.

Operators and owners don’t have the luxury of romance without return. You are stewards of an ecosystem that depends on clarity of purpose. If your guests don’t know whether they’re coming to eat or to listen, they will do neither particularly well.

The irony is that restaurants already have music—better music, in many ways. The sizzle of a pan. The pop of a cork. The low murmur of a room happily occupied. This is the soundtrack people come for, even if they don’t know it. It makes them linger just enough, order just enough, come back just often enough.

Live music asks them to stop being diners and start being an audience. That’s a different contract entirely.

So before you book that band, before you print the flyer, before you convince yourself that this will finally be the thing that sets you apart, ask the hard question: What business am I really in tonight?

If the answer is feeding people well and sending them home happy, you might want to let the room sing on its own.

Are you offering live music at your location? If you are, we can help!

If you are interested in private consulting, do not hesitate to hit the button below.