2 min read

Soft Serve or Scooped

Soft Serve or Scooped

When it comes to ice cream offerings in a food operation, the decision between soft serve and scooped ice cream is a crucial one that can significantly impact customer satisfaction, operational efficiency, and overall business success.

Soft serve ice cream has long been a popular option, with its smooth texture and quick-serve nature appealing to many customers. However, the machinery required to produce soft serve presents numerous challenges that can outweigh its benefits. The soft serve machines manufactured by companies like Taylor and Electrofreeze are notoriously difficult to maintain and prone to breakdowns. These sophisticated pieces of equipment often require specialized technicians for repairs, which can lead to extended periods of downtime and frustrated customers.

Consistency is key in the food industry, whether it pertains to food quality, service, or overall experience. Unfortunately, soft serve machines are inherently inconsistent and unreliable. This is exemplified by the well-known issue of McDonald's frequently non-functional soft serve machines, which has become something of a running joke among consumers. For a food operation, having customers make special trips only to find out that the ice cream machine is down can be disastrous. Not only does this lead to immediate disappointment, but it can also result in negative reviews and a reluctance to return, damaging the business's reputation and bottom line.

Moreover, soft serve ice cream is already widely available at major chains like Dairy Queen, Chick-Fil-A, and McDonald's. This ubiquity makes it challenging for smaller operations to differentiate themselves in the market. Additionally, soft serve typically requires more labor to operate and maintain the machinery, adding to operational costs.

In contrast, scooped ice cream offers numerous advantages. It allows for greater control over quality and consistency, as the ice cream can be prepared in batches and stored appropriately. This method also provides more flexibility in terms of flavors and mix-ins, allowing for creative and unique offerings that can set a business apart from competitors. For operations looking to provide a more artisanal or homemade product, creating their own hard serve ice cream is a viable option that can add value and appeal to customers.

Scooped ice cream also eliminates the headaches associated with temperamental soft serve machines. With proper refrigeration, scooped ice cream is always ready to serve, reducing the likelihood of disappointing customers due to equipment failures. This reliability contributes to a more consistent customer experience and can help build a loyal customer base.

While soft serve ice cream has its place in the market, scooped ice cream emerges as the superior choice for most food operations. Its reliability, consistency, and potential for customization make it a more attractive option for businesses looking to provide a high-quality ice cream experience without the operational challenges associated with soft serve machines. By opting for scooped ice cream, food operations can focus on creating unique, delicious offerings that will keep customers coming back for more.


Are you interested in running an ice cream concept or just adding ice cream to your current menu? We can help!

If you are interested in private consulting, do not hesitate to hit the button below!