Beware of Scammers

Small businesses, particularly those in the catering and cottage industries, are increasingly vulnerable to sophisticated scams that can result in significant financial losses and emotional distress. These scams often exploit the eagerness of small business owners to secure large orders and the trust they place in their clients. Here, we will explore several types of scams targeting caterers and cottage bakers, explain why they are effective, and provide guidance on how to avoid or handle these situations without losing potential legitimate clients.

Digital Check Scam

One of the most insidious scams involves the use of digital checks. Here’s how it typically works:

• A client places a large order, often for an event such as a wedding, corporate function, or birthday party, and offers to pay via digital check.
• The digital check is sent, and the funds appear to be pending in the business's account. This pending status can last for 2-3 days, during which time the business may be reassured by the bank that the check is legitimate.
• Before the check clears, the client contacts the business claiming that the event has been cancelled due to unforeseen circumstances.
• The business, believing the funds are secure, refunds the client out of their own pocket.
• However, when the digital check finally clears, it bounces, leaving the business with a significant financial loss.

This scam is particularly effective because it leverages the urgency and excitement of securing a large order, combined with the temporary illusion of secure payment.

Catering Scam Involving Third-Party Payments

Another common scam targets caterers by involving complex payment arrangements for third parties. Here’s an example:

• A potential client contacts a catering business to arrange a large event, such as a birthday party or corporate gathering.
• After agreeing on the menu and pricing, the client requests a favor: they have hired a DJ or another service provider who does not have a credit card processor. The client asks the caterer to pay the DJ directly and then reimburses the caterer with the credit card payment.
• The caterer, sensing something amiss, may even ask for details such as the DJ’s full name or the name of the party’s host. The client will provide the DJ's information, who in reality, is part of the scam.
• The caterer, even if cautious, proceeds with the payment to the DJ who is affiliated with the scammer, and the client is never heard from again.

This scam works by exploiting the trust and goodwill of the business owner, who may feel obligated to help or want to secure the large order.

Counterfeit Check Scam

Bakers and caterers are also vulnerable to counterfeit check scams, which can be particularly devastating due to the large sums involved. Here’s how it works:

• A client places a significant order, such as 1,000 cupcakes, and sends a check via priority mail.
• The check appears legitimate and clears initially, prompting the business to proceed with the order and purchase all necessary ingredients.
• Before the pickup date, the client requests a reduction in the order and a refund for the difference. The business, believing the funds are secure, agrees.
• However, the check is later discovered to be counterfeit, and the funds are withdrawn from the business’s account. This leaves the business with substantial losses, both in terms of ingredients and labor.

This scam is effective because it uses the initial clearance of the check to build trust, and the urgency of the event to pressure the business into making quick decisions.

Hearing Impaired Scam

Another scam involves a client claiming to be hearing impaired and using a relay service to communicate. Here’s an example:

• A client contacts a catering business using an IP-Relay service, which allows them to communicate via text messages relayed through a third-party operator.
• The client orders a large quantity of food, such as 100 chicken Caesar salads, and agrees on the pricing.
• However, the client’s requests and communication may seem suspiciously formal or lack personal touches, and they may insist on paying the delivery charge with a credit card but demand cash for the food.
• If the business proceeds, they may find themselves victims of a classic 419 scam, where the payment is either counterfeit or never materializes.

This scam leverages the sympathy and accommodation often extended to individuals with disabilities, making it harder for business owners to be skeptical.

Why These Scams Work

Large Orders and Financial Temptation

Small businesses, especially those in the catering and baking industries, often rely on securing large orders to sustain their operations. The promise of a significant order can be very enticing, leading business owners to overlook red flags or rush through the verification process.

Trust and Goodwill

Business owners, particularly in service-oriented industries, are often inclined to trust their clients and want to help. Scammers exploit this trust by creating scenarios that appeal to the business owner’s sense of obligation or goodwill.

Urgency and Pressure

Scams often involve a sense of urgency, whether it’s a sudden event cancellation, a last-minute change in order, or a pressing need for a refund. This urgency can pressure business owners into making hasty decisions without fully verifying the legitimacy of the transaction.

How to Avoid or Deal with These Scams

Verify Clients Thoroughly

Before proceeding with any large order, it is crucial to verify the client thoroughly. This includes:

• Phone Verification: Speak directly with the client over the phone to verify their identity and the details of the order.
• Email and Website Verification: Check if the client’s email and any associated websites appear legitimate and professional.
• Federal ID or Official Documentation: Request official documentation or a federal ID to confirm the client’s identity[2].

Be Cautious of Red Flags

Be wary of any transaction that involves unusual or complex payment arrangements. Here are some red flags to watch out for:

• Unusual Payment Requests: Be cautious if a client asks for payment to be made to a third party or through an unconventional method.
• Last-Minute Changes: Be skeptical of last-minute changes to the order or requests for refunds.
• Lack of Personal Touch: Be wary if the communication lacks personal touches or seems overly formal.

Use Secure Payment Methods

Insist on using secure payment methods that offer some level of protection, such as credit cards or PayPal. Avoid accepting checks or other forms of payment that can be easily counterfeited.

Keep Records and Communicate Clearly

Keep detailed records of all communications and transactions. Clearly communicate your payment policies and any concerns you may have to the client.

Seek Advice

If you are unsure about the legitimacy of an order or payment, seek advice from your bank or a financial advisor. They can help verify the transaction and advise on the best course of action.

Conclusion

Scams targeting caterers and cottage bakers are becoming increasingly sophisticated, exploiting the trust and financial needs of small business owners. By understanding the common types of scams, recognizing the red flags, and implementing robust verification processes, business owners can protect themselves from these threats. Remember, while large orders are tempting, it is always better to err on the side of caution and ensure that every transaction is legitimate and secure.

Were you the victim or the target of a scammer? Safeguard your business!

If you are interested in private consulting, do not hesitate to hit the button below!